O’Melveny Worldwide

Delaware Seeks Comment on Proposal to Create a Precatory Stockholder Proposal Framework if Rule 14a-8 is Rescinded

November 11, 2026

On November 9, 2026, the Council of the Corporation Law Section (the Council) of the Delaware State Bar Association issued a White Paper seeking comment on proposed amendments to the Delaware General Corporation Law (DGCL) that would address “when and how stockholders of a Delaware corporation may submit precatory (non-binding) proposals at annual stockholder meetings and have these proposals included in the corporation’s proxy materials” (the DGCL Proposal).

The DGCL Proposal is in response to recent proposed rulemaking by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the SEC) that would, if adopted, rescind Rule 14a-8 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the Exchange Act), which establishes the federal procedural and substantive framework under which companies are required to include qualifying shareholder proposals in their proxy materials (the Rule 14a-8 Rescission). The Rule 14a-8 Rescission is discussed in greater detail in our September 2026 Client Alert.

As noted in our Client Alert, at this time the corporation law of most states (including Delaware) does not address which stockholder proposals must be included in a company’s proxy statement. The proposed Rule 14a-8 Rescission would therefore leave a gap in the rules governing which stockholder proposals must be included in a company’s proxy statement. The DGCL Proposal seeks to fill this gap and would become effective only if, and when, the Rule 14a-8 Rescission becomes effective.

The Council notes in the White Paper that the prescriptive rules in the DGCL Proposal are intended to avoid “the costs and uncertainty that both corporations and stockholders would incur if the market had to develop its own alternatives to Rule 14a-8.”

Precatory Proposal Cap and Exemptions

The DGCL Proposal would cap the number of precatory proposals (each, a Precatory Proposal) stockholders may require to be presented for a vote at a Delaware corporation’s annual meeting of stockholders (the Precatory Proposal Cap), based on the corporation’s market capitalization.

 

Corporation’s Market Cap

 

$100 billion or more

Less than $100 billion but at least $50 billion

Less than $50 billion but at least $30 billion

Less than $30 billion

Precatory Proposal Cap

3

2

1

0


The Council refers to the limited number of qualifying Precatory Proposals required to be included in a corporation’s proxy statement as the “basket.”

A corporation’s tier would be determined by its market capitalization as of the tenth day before the record date for notice of the corporation’s immediately preceding annual meeting.

Newly public companies would have a five-year grace period before stockholders may submit Precatory Proposals, although corporations may choose to include a shorter time period in their charter. Also, significantly, the DGCL Proposal, if adopted, would not permit the submission of any Precatory Proposal to a corporation with a market capitalization below $30 billion, even if a stockholder would solicit its own proxies for the proposal versus having it included in the corporation’s proxy materials.

Precatory Proposal Opt Out

A corporation may opt out of the Precatory Proposal system through a charter or bylaw provision adopted by stockholders at a meeting held after the fifth anniversary of the corporation’s initial listing, if approved by each class and series of voting capital stock, voting separately. Stockholders of a corporation that has opted out in this manner could not submit any Precatory Proposals, whether or not for inclusion in the corporation’s proxy materials. Other than through an opt out, charters and bylaws could not add to, eliminate or reduce the requirements of the DGCL Proposal.

No Opportunity for Stockholders to Require Vote on Precatory Proposals Outside of the Basket

Proponents of Precatory Proposals that fall outside of the “basket” would not be able to have their proposal voted on at the annual meeting, even if the Precatory Proposal otherwise satisfies the requirements of the DGCL Proposal and the proponent bears the cost of the solicitation.

Precatory Proposal Submission Eligibility

Submission Eligibility

The DGCL Proposal imposes beneficial ownership eligibility thresholds on stockholder proponents of Precatory Proposals.

 

Individual Proponents

Joint Co-Filers (up to nine)

Minimum market value of voting capital stock

$250,000

$1 million, in the aggregate

 

The market value of voting capital stock is determined “as of a measurement date that is the 30th day before the deadline for the corporation’s receipt” of the Proposal using the same method as currently applied under Rule 14a-8. Voting capital stock must be beneficially held for a continuous 365-day period in order to count towards the ownership thresholds.

If the number of Precatory Proposals submitted to a corporation exceeds the corporation’s Precatory Proposal Cap, the corporation is only required to present to stockholders at the annual meeting the Precatory Proposals (up to the Precatory Proposal Cap) submitted by stockholders that beneficially own, either individually or jointly, the most voting stock.

Submission Deadline

Under the DGCL Proposal, in order to be considered for inclusion in a corporation’s proxy materials, Precatory Proposals must be received at a corporation’s principal executive offices “no later than the 180th day before the anniversary” of the preceding year’s annual meeting, with adjustments if the meeting date is advanced by more than 30 days or no annual meeting was held in the preceding year (the Submission Deadline).

The Council estimates that the DGCL Proposal will require advance notice of approximately 180 days, as compared to approximately 165 days under Rule 14a-8 (which imposes a deadline of 120 days before the anniversary of the prior year’s proxy statement), assuming an average of 45 days between the proxy statement and the meeting.

Information Delivery

To submit a Precatory Proposal, a proponent must deliver, on or before the Submission Deadline, the following information:

  • the name and address of the proponent and each co-filer;
  • the text of the Precatory Proposal and any supporting statement (which together may not exceed 500 words);
  • documents signed by each co-filer showing they support the Precatory Proposal and disclaim authority to direct the proponent on, or require co-filer consent for, actions concerning the proposal;
  • if stock is held by a broker or nominee, bank or broker statements establishing that the proponent (and any co-filers, if applicable) satisfies the ownership thresholds (which can be demonstrated using the same types of statements from DTC participants as currently permitted under Rule 14a-8); and
  • a statement from the proponent and each co-filer that they intend to beneficially own the required minimum amount of voting capital stock through the date of the next annual meeting.

Cure Period for Failure to Satisfy Delivery Requirements

The DGCL Proposal requires the corporation to notify a proponent within 14 days of receipt if any Precatory Proposal submission is deficient because the proponent failed to deliver the information listed above (or if the text of the proposal and supporting statement, together, exceeds 500 words) and to give the proponent a single opportunity to cure the deficiency within 14 days after the notice is given.

Bases for Excluding Proposals

Similar to Rule 14a-8, the DGCL Proposal imposes a number of other requirements that must be satisfied before a corporation is required to include the Precatory Proposal in its proxy statement, some of which are based on provisions of Rule 14a-8.

Except for a failure to provide required submission materials or comply with the 500-word limit, for which the cure process is described above, the DGCL Proposal does not provide proponents the ability to cure a deficiency in any of these requirements.

Seven of the bases for exclusion track (but do not duplicate) provisions of Rule 14a-8. The Council notes that “[w]hen applying these provisions, the Delaware judiciary might also be informed by no-action precedents and bulletins from the Staff of the Division of Corporation Finance of the SEC.”

DGCL Proposal – Basis for Exclusion

Parallel Rule 14a-8 Provision

The proponent fails to provide the required materials about the proponent and the co-filers described above.

Rule 14a-8(b)

The Precatory Proposal and supporting statement, together, exceed 500 words.

Rule 14a-8(d)

The Precatory Proposal is not received by the Submission Deadline.

Rule 14a-8(e)

The proponent and co-filers do not satisfy either of the minimum ownership or continuous holding requirements.

Rule 14a-8(b)(1)

Any part of the Precatory Proposal, or the supporting statement, expressly questions the character of one or more nominees for director.*

Rule 14a-8(i)(8)(iii)

The proponent submitted a Precatory Proposal for stockholder action at either of the two preceding annual meetings at which proposals could be presented and it received “for” votes representing less than 15% of the votes cast.

Rule 14a-8(i)(12)

The Precatory Proposal primarily seeks to redress a personal claim or grievance.*

Rule 14a-8(i)(4)

* The White Paper notes that these bases were drafted to impose a higher bar than the parallel provision of Rule 14a-8, in order to reduce the potential for litigation.

Two of the bases for exclusion seek to prevent proponents and companies from undermining the purposes of the DGCL Proposal.

DGCL Proposal – Bases for Exclusion

Purpose

The Precatory Proposal seeks adoption of a board policy, or other governance arrangement, that would result in a statement or commitment by the board to present Precatory Proposals for stockholder action in a manner different from, or as a supplement to, the DGCL Proposal.

Prevents a proponent from proposing an alternative governance framework for Precatory Proposals.

The proponent or a co-filer is a director or officer of the corporation, is controlled by a director or officer, or is acting for a director, an officer or the corporation.

Prevents insiders from “filling the basket” of Precatory Proposals.


Although the Council did not identify the remaining bases for exclusion as being grounded in Rule 14a-8, the first two have loose analogues under federal law. The last basis for exclusion is a “catch all” for any Precatory Proposal that fails to satisfy any other requirement of the DGCL Proposal.

DGCL Proposal – Bases for Exclusion

No rational person would determine that the Precatory Proposal is relevant to the corporation or its business.

The proponent of the Precatory Proposal is serving as the proponent or a co-filer for any other Precatory Proposal in connection with the next annual meeting.

The proponent or any co-filer has failed to satisfy any other requirement of the DGCL Proposal.


The “relevance” requirement is comparable to the relevance exclusion in Rule 14a-8(i)(5), but, unlike Rule 14a-8, is not limited to proposals related to operations and does not impose any specific financial threshold tied to total assets, net sales or earnings or otherwise. To reduce the likelihood of litigation, the “rational person” standard is intended to impose a high bar on the corporation’s ability to exclude a Precatory Proposal on the grounds that it is irrelevant to the corporation.

The DGCL Proposal’s one-proposal requirement is comparable to Rule 14a-8(c), but unlike under Rule 14a-8, a proponent will not be given the opportunity to cure the deficiency.

Requirement to Present Proposal at Meeting

Consistent with Rule 14a-8, no vote may be taken on a Precatory Proposal at a meeting of stockholders unless the proponent (or its proxy holder) attends the annual meeting and requests a vote, or the person presiding over the meeting submits the Precatory Proposal for a vote.

Omission of the Ordinary Business Exclusion and Certain Other Rule 14a-8 Exclusions

The DGCL Proposal does not attempt to replicate the substantive exclusions in Rule 14a-8, such as the ordinary business exclusion. The Council notes that under the DGCL Proposal it will be the corporation’s board of directors, rather than a government body such as the SEC, making judgment calls on whether a Precatory Proposal meets the criteria for inclusion in a corporation’s proxy statement. Rather than allowing an unlimited number of qualifying Precatory Proposals, the DGCL Proposal allows each corporation only a limited number of otherwise eligible Precatory Proposals, where only “the proposals supported by the greatest number of shares” are allowed to go forward to a stockholder vote.

Statements of Opposition in a Corporation’s Proxy Materials

Consistent with the current practice under Rule 14a-8, the DGCL Proposal would allow corporations to include statements in response or opposition to a Precatory Proposal in their proxy statement.

Withdrawing a Precatory Proposal

As under the current federal framework, a proponent of a Precatory Proposal will have the right under the DGCL Proposal to withdraw, or agree with the corporation to amend, an otherwise qualifying Precatory Proposal. A withdrawn Precatory Proposal will not be included in the corporation’s proxy materials for its annual meeting.

Withdrawal or amendment of a qualifying Precatory Proposal will not result in any other submitted Precatory Proposal (excluded due to the Precatory Proposal Cap) becoming eligible to be included in the corporation’s proxy materials.

Limits on Challenges to Application of the Statute to Exclude Proposals

Under the DGCL Proposal, only the proponent of a Precatory Proposal may challenge the corporation’s exclusion of the proposal, and such challenge must be filed in the Delaware Court of Chancery within 30 days after the corporation provides notice of the Precatory Proposals that will be submitted for a stockholder vote. The corporation would bear the burden of establishing that a Precatory Proposal was properly excluded.

Precatory Proposals versus Binding Proposals

The DGCL Proposal specifically creates a framework governing stockholder submissions of precatory, or non-binding, stockholder proposals. Precatory proposals typically ask “a corporation to take specific action” or request “that a corporation prepare a report or make disclosure on a specific topic.” The White Paper states that “[n]either the DGCL nor Delaware court decisions directly address the question of whether stockholders have the right under State law to present precatory proposals.”

In contrast, binding stockholder proposals are stockholder-initiated proposals that, if adopted by a corporation’s stockholders, are binding on the corporation. The categories of permitted binding stockholder proposals are limited by the DGCL and include, among other things, the adoption, amendment, or repeal of bylaws. Delaware courts have upheld advance notice bylaws establishing procedural requirements for stockholders submitting binding stockholder proposals.

The White Paper addresses only the framework for submitting precatory stockholder proposals and having them included in the corporation’s proxy materials. The existing Delaware law framework for binding stockholder proposals would remain unchanged, meaning that stockholders would not have a right under Delaware law to require inclusion of those proposals in a corporation’s proxy materials (but could continue to present lawful proposals under the corporation’s advance notice bylaws and solicit their own proxies for the binding proposals).

Next Steps

Comments are due on the White Paper within 60 days of its release date, or by January 8, 2027. If the Council’s revised draft is approved by the Corporation Law Section and the Executive Committee of the Delaware State Bar Association, it would be submitted to the Delaware General Assembly in the first half of 2027.


This memorandum is a summary for general information and discussion only and may be considered an advertisement for certain purposes. It is not a full analysis of the matters presented, may not be relied upon as legal advice, and does not purport to represent the views of our clients or the Firm. Shelly Heyduk, an O’Melveny partner licensed to practice law in California; Rob Plesnarski, an O’Melveny partner licensed to practice law in the District of Columbia; Andra Troy, an O’Melveny partner licensed to practice law in New York; Ashley Gust, an O’Melveny counsel licensed to practice law in California; and Aliza Cohen, an O’Melveny resource attorney licensed to practice law in California, contributed to the content of this newsletter. The views expressed in this newsletter are the views of the authors except as otherwise noted.

© 2026 O’Melveny & Myers LLP. All Rights Reserved. Portions of this communication may contain attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Please direct all inquiries regarding New York’s Rules of Professional Conduct to O’Melveny & Myers LLP, 1301 Avenue of the Americas, Suite 1700, New York, NY, 10019, T: +1 212 326 2000.